
On the train to work today, I realised I couldn’t log in to my online banking, hence I couldn’t check that a direct debit had stopped. This was frustrating, and after navigating through the worlds worst phone-tree system just to hear a “Yes”, I decided to start sketching how things could be better. When I got to work, I dumped my notes into Omnigraffle using Patrick Crowley’s iPhone stencil and that’s where I stopped.
Obviously wire-framing a mobile banking application takes a little more than a train journey to do successfully, but none the less I believe what I sketched out is a better interface to banking than I currently have, mobile or otherwise.
The beauty of constraints
Mobile sites tend to be lightweight equivalents of their desktop counterparts. They usually ignore the context of mobility, but that’s a separate issue. What I find interesting is that the “lightweight equivalent” usually turns out to be a better site, full stop. With banking, the “benefits” of a fully featured desktop site are car insurance, house insurance, loan applications, mortgage applications, savings schemes. Undoubtedly most of these have a place somewhere, but they really junk up the interface most of time.
A good way to focus your site, is to design it for the mobile, impatient, and angry user who just wants to X,Y,Z. In the case of banking this could be check balance, view account activity, pay credit card bill. Why not just launch this anorexic application, and then see what’s missing? In my experience users are far quicker to tell you what features they want added to an application, than to list the features they can live without. The best way to lose weight, is to not put it on in the first place.
App School
If you have an idea for a cool (possibly mobile) web app, we’ll build it for you. We’ll even cover 95% of the cost. Just be sure to get your applications in by Thursday.
6 Comments
Not to be too negative but I can’t see an Irish bank having an online banking app on an iPhone in the next two or three years at the very least - they are just too slow in developing things and taking into account “edge” technologies like say Macs ;).
AIB online banking works fine on the iPhone though. Great for bad news before you go out for the night!
Posted by Stewart Curry at 5:20 pm on 13 October, 2008.
It’s not negative Stu, it’s just honest.
I wouldn’t insist on an iPhone app, any sort of small screen optimised effort, in fact any effort at making banking nice would be good. It was AIB I was trying to use, but some javascript fanciness was stopping my login.
Cheers for the comment
Des
Posted by Des Traynor at 5:31 pm on 13 October, 2008.
There’s something wrong with that picture. I think you spent far more on booze on Saturday night. Don’t get me wrong, I was a very happy recipient of the pints and sambuca (which I sipped in a very civilised fashion)
Posted by Lar at 1:04 pm on 14 October, 2008.
Yeah, I don’t think I could have fit Saturday nights activities into one screen to be honest Lar
Posted by Des Traynor at 1:21 pm on 14 October, 2008.
A case in point is Digg. On desktop I avoid Digg like the plague but oddly it is one of the first sites I turn to on my iPhone when I have some time to kill. Simple, quick, clean interface, much better than the “full sized” one.
Posted by Paul M. Watson at 6:17 pm on 15 October, 2008.
Good article, couldn’t agree more. Start with the purpose of the app and add to it.
I am lucky enough to have a bank that is already on the iPhone-wagon. It’s fast and works so much better than the “desktop” version.
http://www.anz.com/mobilebanking/?pid=grm-hb-hp-oct-08-iphone
Steven
Posted by Steven Tan at 7:03 am on 26 October, 2008.
2 Trackbacks
[...] “The benefits of constraints,” Contrast [...]
Posted by Nathan Peretic Dot Com » Blog Archive » contrast benefits of constraints at 2:01 am on 14 October, 2008
[...] provide feature X is easier when time constraints and money is tighter. The guys over at Contrast have a great post on the benefits of this, and well the recession is a pretty big [...]
Posted by Why the recession is good for software entrepreneurs at 9:39 am on 15 October, 2008